Thyroid School, Issue #12// Nourishment VS Deprivation

If you’ve actually gained weight from dieting and exercising, you’ll want to continue reading.

Gosh, it’s so tempting, isn’t it? The whole eating-less, working out more to lose weight approach.

I get it. Logically and mathematically, it makes sense.

However, our bodies are more like thermostats than calculators and the thyroid is in charge of it all.

There are a few big things that send the message to the thyroid to slow down.

1. Stress (both physical and emotional)

2. Under-eating

3. Autoimmunity

Stress

Survival is a priority. Survival stress responses will always trump other non-essential functions (important, but not “essential” for survival) like digestion, metabolism, reproduction, sleep. When our body senses heightened stress, the thyroid downregulates those non-essential functions and upregulates survival mode. This is otherwise known as fight/flight/freeze versus rest/digest/reproduce/metabolize.


We all have a built-in threshold for stress resiliency and different stressors fill up our stress buckets more than others. Some stressors are unavoidable and out of our control, so instead of adopting a “no stress” mindset, it’s important to “know your stress”. Acknowledge the things you can control and the things you can’t and adjust accordingly.

Things that stress your body that you may not realize:

– over-exercising

– being too sedentary

– not sleeping well

– eating poor quality foods

– weighing yourself daily

– feeling under-valued and under-appreciated

– internalized, suppressed, and repressed trauma

– pollution (both indoor and outdoor)

– toxic relationships

Under-eating:

This is a BIG one that I most often tackle in my 1:1 work with clients. Diet dogma and culture have brainwashed us into thinking that we should starve ourselves into a smaller pant size and that eating to satisfaction is a negative thing. Food is fulfilling both physically and emotionally, and you should never feel shame about either.

Our basal metabolic rate (BMR) is the amount of calories burned at rest– that is: no movement beyond breathing and essential survival functions. For the average woman, the BMR is above 1200 calories per day. Read that again: the MINIMUM amount of calories your body needs when you’re literally lying in bed is 1200 calories.

When you underreat, your metabolism (governed mostly by your thyroid) turns down in an effort to preserve energy. As a safety net, you will also shift from fat-burning to fat-storing to make certain that you have reserves in case there is a prolonged period without food.

How do you know if you’re eating enough?

1. Tap into your hunger and fullness cues. Are you always pre-occupied with food? Do you get super foggy-headed and exhausted during the day? Do you lose control in the pantry when you get home from work? Those are common tendencies of an undernourished body.

2. If you’re disconnected from hunger/fullness cues (which is NOT uncommon if you have yo-yo dieted a lot), you can do some tracking and calculations to give you a ballpark. I like using unbiased and scientifically proven equations to give an idea of calorie needs. You can compare your intakes (usually by tracking in something like ChronoMeter or My Fitness Pal) to what science tells you you need.

3. Autoimmunity

I’ve covered this a lot and will continue to, but the gist of it is that unmanaged autoimmune disease will progressively worsen your thyroid hormone output as the tissue of the thyroid continues to degrade.

Until next time,

Nicole

Meet Nicole Fennel Functional Dietitian

Hey There, I'm Nicole!

I'm Nicole, Integrative & Functional Registered Dietitian Nutritionist — and a Hashimoto's patient and busy momma of three who has been in your shoes. I spent years trying to figure out why I felt so off despite doing all the "right" things, and that experience completely shaped the way I work with women today.

My whole approach is built around nourishing your body with real food you actually want to eat, not white-knuckling your way through a six-week protocol that leaves you more exhausted and more confused than when you started. Because restriction doesn't heal anything. Real, sustainable nourishment does.

I'm a college professor and educator at heart— I teach a range of classes from freshman level "Introduction to Nutrition" and graduate-level Women's Health and Nutrition courses, and that passion for making complex science click in plain English is woven into everything I do. If you leave a session without actually understanding why we're doing what we're doing, we haven't done our job.

I love going on long walks while listening to an audiobook (my FAVORITE is The Count of Monte Cristo, but I'm currently reading Lord of the Rings), being totally outnumbered with my three wild kiddos, eating yummy food, sipping a good cup of coffee, and (trying) to crochet!
Freebies For you!
Kickstart your journey without feeling overwhelmed! Check out our free resources for women living with thyroid issues, Hashimoto's, PCOS, insulin resistance, weight loss resistance, and exhaustion.
work with us
Whether you're running on fumes no matter how much you sleep, trying to make sense of a Hashimoto's or thyroid diagnosis, dealing with periods that knock you completely sideways, navigating PCOS, struggling with cholesterol or blood sugar that won't cooperate, or carrying weight that refuses to budge no matter what you try — please know you are not alone. And more importantly, there is an actual reason you feel this way.
At Chews Food Wisely, we're not here to hand you a meal plan and wish you luck. We're here to look at your full picture — your labs, your symptoms, your life — and find the connections that explain why your body has been doing what it's been doing. Then we build you back up with real food, realistic strategies, and a plan that fits your actual life. Not a protocol designed for someone else's body.

Let’s fix those hormone imbalances that are making you feel crummy!

EMAIL:
hello@chewsfoodwisely.com

VIRTUAL APPOINTMENTS ONLY
Business Mailing Address:
2525 Robinhood Street
Houston, Texas 77005

© 2026 Chews Food Wisely. All Rights Reserved. Website Designed by AVM
Disclaimers   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms of Purchase   |   Terms and Conditions

By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies. We use cookies to provide you with a great experience and to help our website run effectively.